Skip to content
Winemaking.net

Faults

Diagnose it by what you can smell.

Sensory thresholds vary between people by an order of magnitude, which is why one taster is certain a wine is faulty and another cannot find it. Most of these cannot be reversed, and this page says so rather than selling you a cure.

Oxidation

Smells like
Bruised apple, sherry, nuts. Whites turn deep gold, reds turn brown at the rim.
Cause
Oxygen exposure, usually through headspace, a leaking bung or too little free SO2 for the wine's pH.
Detection threshold
Detectable long before it is obvious; colour usually moves first.
Can it be fixed
Nothing reverses it. Blending away a lightly oxidised lot is the only real option.

Prevent it
Top up, exclude air, and dose sulphite to a molecular target rather than a free-SO2 habit.

Volatile acidity

Smells like
Vinegar, and at lower levels nail polish remover from the ethyl acetate that comes with it.
Cause
Acetobacter converting alcohol to acetic acid in the presence of oxygen, or a stressed ferment.
Detection threshold
Around 0.6 to 0.9 g/L acetic acid for most tasters.
Can it be fixed
Not reversible at home. Small amounts can be blended out.

Prevent it
Keep vessels full, keep fruit flies out, and never leave a stuck ferment sitting warm.

Brettanomyces

Smells like
Barnyard, plaster, band-aid, smoked meat. Some people like a little of it; almost nobody likes a lot.
Cause
A spoilage yeast in reds, thriving at high pH and low free SO2, often living in old oak.
Detection threshold
Widely variable. Some tasters cannot detect it at all.
Can it be fixed
Sterile filtration removes the organism. The aroma compounds already formed stay.

Prevent it
Molecular SO2 above 0.5 mg/L, clean barrels, and do not let a red sit warm with sugar left in it.

Hydrogen sulphide

Smells like
Rotten egg. If left, it develops into mercaptans that smell of onion, garlic or burnt rubber.
Cause
Stressed yeast, usually short of nitrogen, producing sulphur compounds during fermentation.
Detection threshold
Very low. Most people detect H2S at a few micrograms per litre.
Can it be fixed
Splash-rack early and it often blows off. Once it has become a mercaptan it is far harder, and copper additions are a last resort.

Prevent it
Adequate yeast nutrient, added in stages, and a fermentation temperature the strain can actually cope with.

Cork taint

Smells like
Wet cardboard, damp basement. At low levels it does not smell of anything: it just strips the fruit out of the wine.
Cause
TCA, formed when chlorine compounds meet mould, usually in cork but sometimes in the cellar itself.
Detection threshold
A few nanograms per litre; among the lowest sensory thresholds known.
Can it be fixed
None for the bottle. If several bottles are affected, suspect the cellar rather than the cork.

Prevent it
Never use chlorine-based sanitiser anywhere near a winery.

Refermentation in the bottle

Smells like
Unexpected fizz, cloudiness, and in the worst case bottles that leak or burst.
Cause
Residual sugar plus surviving yeast, bottled without stabilisation.
Detection threshold
Obvious once it starts.
Can it be fixed
Chill everything immediately and open carefully. Assume every bottle is affected.

Prevent it
Ferment fully dry, or stabilise with sorbate plus sulphite. Sorbate alone without sulphite invites a geranium smell instead.

Most of these trace back to sulphite management. Check yours against your pH.